What Makes Something Feel Real?
19 NovemberOn authenticity, and why fiction sometimes feels more truthful than reality.
I’ve always been fascinated by how differently people can behave depending on who they’re with. Someone can be completely relaxed among friends, then become almost a different person at work, especially around their boss. I know it happens all the time, but I find it difficult to understand. I’ve never felt the need to behave differently depending on who’s sitting across from me. Obviously, you don’t have the same conversation with everyone, but you’re still the same person. At least, that’s how I’ve always seen it.
I notice something similar when people have their photograph taken. Someone is talking to you perfectly normally, then a camera comes out and suddenly their whole expression changes. A different smile, a particular angle, a look they’ve probably practised in front of a mirror. It’s almost as if they’re putting on another face. I can watch people doing this endlessly, partly because it’s something I don’t really recognise in myself.
Of course, that doesn’t mean they’re being dishonest. Maybe it’s simply a way of feeling more comfortable or confident. But I do find myself wondering why we feel the need to present ourselves differently, and whether we’re even aware of doing it.
These thoughts came back to me recently when I attended an Academy screening in Amsterdam of You Can See Everything, by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. I absolutely loved it. It’s funny, uncomfortable and at times almost impossible to get your head around. I left the screening with more questions than I had when I walked in, which is usually a good sign.
The filmmakers spend time with Elizabeth Holmes in the weeks before she goes to prison. We all know something about her story, so naturally you arrive with certain expectations. But watching her is a strange experience. At times she seems almost unbelievably naïve, and then you wonder whether she’s actually much smarter than everyone around her. Does she genuinely remember so little? Is she choosing her words very carefully? Or does she believe everything she’s saying?
And then there’s Nathan Fielder. If you know his work, you’ll know that he’s particularly good at making you question what’s genuine and what’s part of the performance. But here I found myself wondering about something else. Could he actually be falling for Holmes? Does he become so involved with her that it starts affecting the film he’s making? Or is that exactly what he wants us to think? The fascinating thing is that his relationship with her, whatever it really is, inevitably influences how we see her too.
I don’t want to give anything away, because so much of the pleasure of this film comes from trying to work things out for yourself. But I kept thinking about it afterwards. How quickly we decide whether someone is trustworthy, intelligent, sincere or simply pretending. And how easily those impressions can change.
There’s something quite funny about the fact that we spend so much time trying to work out whether people in real life are being genuine, while happily sitting through two hours of actors pretending to be someone else. We know a fictional film has been written, rehearsed, shot and edited. We know that what we’re watching never actually happened. And yet we can come away feeling that we’ve witnessed something completely truthful.
I’ve always loved that contradiction. A fictional character can sometimes feel more real to us than someone we’re watching in a documentary. Perhaps because what we recognise in a character isn’t necessarily their story, but something in the way they feel, react or behave.
It also makes me think about how well we really know the people around us. We trust people because of what they’ve told us, what we’ve experienced together and how they’ve behaved over time. And gradually we build a picture of who they are. But what happens when we discover something that doesn’t fit that picture? Have they changed, or have we simply been looking at them differently all along?
I don’t think there’s an easy answer, and I’m not sure I’d want one. It’s one of the things I enjoy most about cinema. A film can leave you uncertain about a character, or even about what you’ve just watched, and still make you feel something very strongly. Sometimes I find myself thinking about those films much longer than the ones where everything is neatly explained.
Maybe that’s why You Can See Everything made such an impression on me. I still don’t quite know what to believe, or even who I believe. And I rather like that.
We go to the cinema knowing that people are pretending to be someone else. And every now and then, somewhere in all that pretending, we recognise something that feels completely real.